1) keep the Gehrig. Hopefully it is the older model with the cool finger adjustment strap on the back.
2)give the G41 to a friend that I can trust will not let the box get crushed. I would be paranoid that it would get ruined in my house. Three kids and two dogs just pose to much risk!
3)sell the tipped finger but only to someone that would agree to sell it back to me after the drwaing for the t-shirt is over.
Keep the Gehrig (never owned one; always wanted one). Shop around the Boxed G41 and tipped finger and sell the one that stands to go higher. Give the remaining glove to softball66 for all he's done over the years to nurture the hobby.