by BretMan » August 11th, 2008, 10:52 pm
Other than possible differences in condition (one glove being well-worn and another in excellent shape, for instance) I would have to chalk it up to luck-of-draw with eBay auctions. You never know who happens to see the auction or what they're willing to pay.
There probably isn't a huge demand for Pinson-endorsed gloves, and sometimes if a couple of them are selling at the same time, one can kind of steal some bids from the other.
One other possibility- perhaps the three gloves were of varying degrees of "quality". Of those three models, I can only find one- the 42-157- in the old Spalding catalogs. It was a "cheapie", retailing for $5.95 in 1965 (the top-line Spaldings were listed at $42.95).
There is a 42-147 Trapocket model listed in the early 60's and it retailed at $8.45. There's another Pinson model- a 42-253 "Autograph" model- listed at $10.95, still well below even the "mid-price" range for those years. And that is the most expensive Vada Pinson glove in the catalogs.
Perhaps one of the gloves you saw was a higer-end "Personal" model that isn't listed in the retail catalogs. Other than a big difference in condition or quality, I would bet the price differences were just random eBay price fluctuations.