These Spaldings and the Shoeless Joe gloves are some of the coolest I have ever seen. I love how they combine a vintage look with modern glove technology to make a "new-old" glove. However ...
I think they look awesome, but, like others have said about the Sandlot series and Brett has mentioned here, I am not sure they are of the best quality they could be.
I had a leather bomber jacket when I was in college, made of "distressed" leather. It
looked like it had been made years ago, and
had seen a lot of action when I made bomber raids over the enemy 
and it was really fashionable at the time. However, the leather was easily scuffed, scarred and stained beyond the level of the fashionable distressing process. I didn't feel like it was holding up very well. I think the distressing process that gave it its vintage look also literally distressed the leather, making it less durable.
That's what I am afraid of with these vintage gloves. The "vintage-ing" process may make them less durable.
Yes, I still have my first glove.