Vintage Baseball Glove Forum

The big three Mickey Mantle gloves and mitt came up for auction on ebay this month and I was surprised at the prices. The MMP HOH, XPG6 HOH and DCT HOH were all up this month with the two gloves not meeting reserve and the DCT basemitt going for a ridiculously low $263. I remember a time when that rare mitt would bring 4-5 times that amount. The recession has sure taken a toll on some popular player models. The condtion of the DCT was not great since it was a well used glove in its day but someone got a lot of enjoyment from it and that is what they are made for. The MMP did not meet the $399 reserve and a lesser condition model solid in the $150 range. THe XPG6 was overpriced at an $895 reserve.
MMP HOH

XPG6 HOH

DCT HOH

Just say no to inked gloves ... yuck. Of course, I inked my Billy Williams endorsement when I was a kid, and wrote my name all over it.

I, too, have been tracking Mantles for a while and think the upper condition ones have held their value quite well. The ones below that in condition are the ones that are settling a bit. In this case, though, that is probably the most modern looking MMP I think I've ever seen, and the DCT just doesn't grab me either.

Earlier in the month a tough model MM8 picture box I believe went over $1,400 but didn't meet it's $1,795 reserve.

Musials also seem to be doing well. I had interest in both of these HOH models but came up short. The first is the legendary TG12 that went for $275, and the second a beauty correct-hand PM 3-finger that went for $175. I'm asking myself why I didn't bid more on the PM which are real tough to get in that condition. Congrats!

If someone on here won this glove, when you get it, I'd love to see a better picture of the the tag. I have an American Quality crescent and I want to see if this one has a similar/same tag and maybe a location where it was made. Thanks

So I'm a lefty and the Stall and Dean was $299.00 or best offer so I offered what I thought it was worth $135.00 including shipping. Seller said yes

I think that's a pretty good pickup at $135, Murph ... not too many 30s buckleback fielder Stall & Deans floating around. The funny thing is that's what I offered early on when they initially listed it (with their Make Offer option) and they quickly shot it down. I'm glad you were able to get it. Congrats.

Note to all, there is an ebay Stall and Dean "Stuffy McInnes" that ends soon that I only mention because another collector asked me about behind the scenes, and I know it isn't flying under the radar. This was listed several weeks ago with a high opening but the seller didn't answer any questions about the endorsement (to at least two people). I won it, but before sending it the seller finally answered my previous question and said there was no endorsement visible. We ended up canceling the auction. Later , unsolicited, they sent me an email saying that they could see the endorsement but wouldn't elaborate when I asked additional questions. I've asked them the question again in the auction to get official clarification, but at this point in time still haven't received an answer. The whole thing has been a little strange in that they elaborated on some things -- using more advanced terms -- but the degree of endorsement is still a mystery. Unless I get a clear answer I am out and just thought you should know. It could be beauty, though. Good luck!

The month ended in a flurry with two sellers in particular selling some really nice leather. There are too many nice ones to list individually so check them out (the pictures expand if you click on them). What was the best buy of the bunch? I like the white Reach 1" web.

When Robbie thins down a little, we all are lucky dogs:


Next up is a collector out of Canada who has quite the eye for condition:


Note, there is a discussion on the Maris glove in another thread "What's the Rukus"

also this Ruth at $515.00

I'll end this month with a couple good values and officially pass the baton to Briggs86 ... have fun!

How can you go wrong with a crescent under $100 (in this case $85)?



And this Peerless Jimmy Gleason buckleback only went for $20.50




Like usual, I'm sure I missed several other good values or top gloves. What else was interesting in July?