by BretMan » August 12th, 2013, 6:54 pm
Saddle soap is just that- a soap, intended for cleaning leather, not necessarily conditioning it. If you use saddle soap, use it sparingly and try to rinse every bit of it off after cleaning your glove. Any left behind will eventually migrate to the surface and that's how you get that white gunk. I've also read that saddle soap is very acidic and if left behind can actually damage leather fibers in the long run.
This is a hard lesson I learned myself years ago. Way back in the 80's I used saddle soap on my playing gloves. I don't know for sure if you can attribute it that, but a couple of these gloves I still have today and the leather about as worn out as any glove I've ever seen. It has a "mushy" feel to it and doesn't hold it's shape well at all. When I first started collecting old gloves, I went to the old tried and true saddle soap and these gloves will still bleed out white goo from time to time.
I suppose that you could try cleaning the leaher with something else to see if you can get rid of any residue. Two good cleaners I use a lot are a 50/50 mix of Murphys Oil Soap, mixed in a spray bottle, and Fast Orange hand cleaner (with lanolin, but without the pumice added). The MOS/H2O mix I use for lighter cleaning. The Fast Orange I use on really gritty, grimy, greasy, oily gloves. It's probably what I'd use to get rid of any saddle soap.