I had a friend who received a Kelly glove as a prize for being no. 1 at a showcase. He said that it wa sthe best glove he had ever used, and that it was perfectly broken in the day he got it.
Another smaller glove company (but not made in the USA) is Valle Baseball Gloves. www.vallebaseball.com . I purchased one of his Tiger series gloves for my son and it quickly became his favorite. John Valle had a table set up at a coaches convention this past January and I had a chance to check out the entire line. I must say they are very nice gloves. Personally I love the HOF Series.