This scarce Neumann-Newvine catchers mitt sold for $32 on ebay. has a nice vintage look. Great cloth patch but the stain on the front didn't help price-wise.
A 1940's Hutch "Harry Craft" model sold for $55 on ebay. Well built and top of the line in its day. Features the patented Dubow "outseams". Nice cloth patch with patent stamp.